So you've made it into law school, and you're all geared up for the academic year. You've got your textbooks, casebooks, lecture notes and Ginger Snail subscriptions for your modules. But for students who want to become lawyers after graduation, there is a little more you must prepare for – the vacation schemes and training contract applications. Typically, you'd start applying for these coveted positions in your second year of law school. So, how does one prepare for these applications?
In this article, we share one of the many strategies you could adopt when applying for vacation schemes and training contracts. Remember, this is only a guide, so feel free to adapt it to your study schedule and lifestyle.
The application preparation process can be split into three parts:
We recommend maintaining a habit of keeping in touch with current commercial affairs – small steps, over time, go a long way. We suggest:
One might be inclined to cram commercial awareness readings into a short and intense period right before their vacation scheme or training contract interviews. However, we would advise against such an approach – many events that are relevant to your commercial awareness develop over long periods (e.g., the changing economic climate and how that affects the industries or practice areas you might be interested in) and therefore developing general commercial awareness over an extended period might be more beneficial than a massive binge of commercial developments covering only the week before your interviews.
We recommend doubling the amount of time spent on reading business news. Pay attention to, e.g.:
One thought that might cross your mind is, "There are so many things going on in the world; where do I even start?!" Before the application period begins, read as you please – try to get a general sense of business news based on the points mentioned above. During the application period, let your focus on commercial affairs be guided by the areas that interest you and the "Frontrunner Firms" (we define this term in the section "Firm Awareness" below). For example, if a Frontrunner Firm specialises in aviation transactions, and that is an area you are interested in, focus some of your commercial awareness reading on that area. Here is a true story of a short conversation one of us had during an open day:
Lawyer: So, what areas of law are you interested in?
Open Day Student: I'm quite interested in aviation and M&A.
Lawyer: I see! So, what do you think about Qatar Airways’ acquisition of a 10% stake in IAG?
Fortunately, this student was able to have an opinion on the issue and answer the question because he had chanced upon a news article discussing this very transaction the week before (https://www.theguardian.com/business/2015/jan/30/qatar-airways-10-percent-stake-iag).
Two things can be said about the above exchange. First, if you want to express a particular interest in a particular field, be ready to defend that interest. The more specific you are about any topic, the greater your implied familiarity. That said, we think it might be particularly impressive if you can defend your position. Generally, after an open day, HR teams will send a firm-wide request for impressions on the participating students, and so it would help a student stand out if a lawyer says, "This student expressed an interest in one of our core practice areas and was able to discuss current developments in the area" – high risk, high reward. The other takeaway from the above exchange is that the student/interviewee can somewhat steer the conversation. For instance, the question about the aviation transaction would never have come up if a different interest was expressed.
The entire preparation and application journey requires students (law and non-law who also desire to become lawyers) to look outwards at the world (commercial awareness) and inwards with a degree of introspection. Firms are commercial entities concerned with profits per partner and billable hours, but you, as an individual, will work in teams where building rapport is essential. This is where one's consideration of firm culture comes to the fore. Therefore, you need to understand your culture "fit". Consider your answers to the following questions:
The answers to some of these questions may be found through online research. Some may have to be answered by lawyers you meet at open days or law fairs. The answers to these questions should inform how you rank the firms you will be applying for. This exercise is also helpful in other aspects of the application process. For instance, the application forms of some firms will ask you, "Why us"? It might be insufficient (and unconvincing) for an applicant to want to join a firm purely based on a practice area reputation because several firms can be "leaders" in a practice area at the same time. Further, students may be perceived as too distant from the legal profession to make a compelling case solely on that basis. Mentioning what you like about a firm's culture also shows that you care about finding a firm that is the right fit for you (and, likewise, you being a fit for them). It is essential that you end up at a firm that is (if not perfect) a good fit for your working style and personality – it will facilitate your learning, and it is a joy to work with people you have a good rapport with. Being a lawyer can often be a gruelling (but rewarding) endeavour, especially if your sights are set on the Big Law or Magic Circle firms. We speak from experience — even brutal hours can be enjoyable and somewhat positive experiences (usually with hindsight) with the right team.
Create a list of firms (the "List") that you would like to join, keeping in mind three "criteria":
Arrange the firms on the List with the firms that meet all three criteria at the top and those that meet the fewest criteria at the bottom.
While it is great to focus only on the firms that you want, the brutal truth is that there are far more applicants than spaces, and the system for selecting candidates will never be perfect. We believe the application process is a bit (though not solely) of a numbers game – not everyone gets their top choice. Sometimes, even applicants who may be a perfect fit for a firm might be overlooked among the hundreds of applications firms get each year. Another truth is that some legal experience is better than none, and any training contract can serve as a stepping stone to your dream firm. You might grow fond of the firm you train at, even if it was not your first choice. Having been through this process and spoken to many colleagues who have done likewise, most students (from our perspective) may have an idea of the practice area they want to go into, but these preferences may change as their exposure to other practice areas widen their horizons on the career trajectories available to them. The point is to make a list – not just a handful of firms, but a list of substantial length (think more than fifteen).
Let's call your top three firms the "Prime Firms", and let's call the following top 5 firms the "Bench Firms" (these numbers are just suggestions; feel free to adjust to a "Prime"-"Bench" breakdown you feel most comfortable with). Once you have populated the List, conduct in-depth research on the Prime and Bench firms. Pay attention to (and make notes) about:
I used to compile and print little information bundles for my top 10 firms.
In this phase, you will complete and fire out your applications. The vacation scheme/training contract application period runs for about two months. Once the application period opens, start filling in your application forms (some of these are pretty darn long).
A couple of suggestions:
Some firms will reply within a couple of weeks, letting you know whether your application is being moved to the next stage. Some firms require you to take certain tests (e.g., a verbal reasoning test, Watson-Glaser test, personality test, numerical test, etc.). Further, some firms might follow up with a telephone interview. Fortunately, you can practice for these tests (there is an abundance of practice tests online), and for phone interviews, you can have your notes in front of you during the interview.
Here are a couple of tips for phone interviews:
These tips are, of course, far less helpful for video interviews.
The application period can be challenging for some because this is when the rejections stream in. Don't take them to heart – look back at those applications and consider how they could be improved. For each rejection, cross out the rejecting firm and begin an application for the next two firms on your List. Rinse, repeat and polish.
We've discussed preparing for applications and phone interviews. What do we do when we make it past those and are invited to a video or in-person interview? In-person interviews, at their core, are best approached as "conversations". In some ways, they are like "first dates" – you know a bit about the firm, and they know a bit about you, and the interview is the chance for you both to know each other better. If you've done the above preparation, we believe you will also be ready for your interviews. In our view, when you are asked about commercial or legal issues, the interviewer cares more about your thought process rather than you knowing the actual answer. For example, "Do you think arbitration is better for settling disputes than litigating in the courts?"
In the:
We'll leave you with one more suggestion. While you may have done a great deal of reflection about the practice area you are interested in and the firm culture that attracts you, always keep an open mind to new ideas and perspectives because there is only so much you can learn from research. Actual experience working in a law firm might deviate from your expectations in a good or not-so-good way, but in any case, it will bring you clarity and insight into life as a lawyer. We think applicants who reiterate their appreciation that there is a lot to learn about legal practice and expressly commit to keeping an open mind about learning from any practice area they may be assigned to will make a good impression.
We hope this article on how to approach the vacation scheme and training contract applications will be helpful to you, and we wish you all the best in your applications!
Go get em!
Sincerely,
Ginger Snail
Ginger Snail Pte Ltd 68 Circular Road #02-01 SINGAPORE (049422)
Ginger Snail and the Ginger Snail logo are registered trademarks of Ginger Snail Pte Ltd.